ROAS isn't profit: the 10-minute check every Shopify founder should do
A 3x ROAS sounds great. But is it making you money? Here's how to work out your break-even ROAS on the back of a napkin.
“We hit a 3x ROAS this month!” sounds like a win. Sometimes it is. Sometimes it means you spent £10,000 to make £30,000 of sales and lost money on every one of them.
ROAS (return on ad spend) tells you how much revenue came back for every £1 you spent on ads. It doesn’t tell you anything about profit. To know if your ads make money, you need one more number: your break-even ROAS.
Step 1: Work out what’s left before ads
Take an average order and subtract every cost of fulfilling it, except advertising. Here’s a made-up example:
| £ | |
|---|---|
| Average order value | 80.00 |
| Product cost (40%) | −32.00 |
| Shipping and packaging | −6.00 |
| Payment fees (about 2%) | −1.60 |
| Returns allowance (5% of sales) | −4.00 |
| Left before ads | 36.40 |
So before you spend a penny on ads, each order leaves you £36.40, or 45.5% of the order value. That’s your margin before ads. (The fancy name is contribution margin before marketing.)
Step 2: Turn it into a break-even ROAS
Here’s the formula:
Break-even ROAS = 1 ÷ margin before ads
In our example: 1 ÷ 0.455 = 2.2.
That means for every £1 you spend on ads, you need £2.20 of sales just to break even. Anything below 2.2 loses money. Anything above it makes money.
Step 3: See what different ROAS levels really mean
Same £80 order, different ROAS:
| ROAS | Ad cost per order | Profit per order |
|---|---|---|
| 2.0x | £40.00 | −£3.60 (a loss) |
| 2.2x | £36.36 | £0.04 (break even) |
| 3.0x | £26.67 | £9.73 |
| 4.0x | £20.00 | £16.40 |
That “great” 3x ROAS? It leaves you about £9.73 an order, roughly 12% of the sale. Fine, but not exactly champagne.
And if your product cost is 55% rather than 40%, your break-even ROAS jumps to over 3. Suddenly that 3x ROAS is losing money.
Three things that make this even trickier
1. Platform ROAS is usually flattering. Meta and Google both take credit for sales they influenced, and often for the same sale. Add up what every platform claims and it’s usually more than your actual revenue. A better reality check is MER (marketing efficiency ratio): total revenue ÷ total ad spend, across everything.
2. New and returning customers aren’t equal. A returning customer who would have bought anyway, clicking a branded search ad, inflates ROAS without adding much. A brand-new customer at a lower ROAS might be worth far more over time.
3. Discounts move the goalposts. A 20% off code cuts your order value but not your product cost. Your break-even ROAS on promo weeks is much higher than you think.
What to do with this
- Work out your break-even ROAS today. Literally ten minutes with your Shopify reports and a calculator.
- Share it with whoever runs your ads, in-house or agency. Ask them to report against it.
- Start tracking MER alongside platform ROAS, every week.
- Work out break-even ROAS for your top products separately. They’re rarely the same.
Revenue is vanity. Profit is sanity. ROAS is somewhere in the middle, and only useful if you know where your line is.
Skip the napkin: plug your own numbers into the free profit & break-even ROAS calculator, which handles VAT too. And if you want your real profit by product and by channel, that’s what the Profit Leak Audit does.