Where should your free shipping threshold be?
Most brands pick a round number that feels right. This works out where your threshold earns the most profit, based on your order values, margin and shipping.
Your orders, by basket value
Profit at every threshold
Monthly profit compared with charging everyone for shipping. Above the line, the threshold pays for itself.
Too low, too high, just right
- Too low and you give free shipping to orders that would have happened anyway.
- Too high and almost nobody bothers to reach it, so it does nothing.
- The sweet spot is where extra orders and bigger baskets earn more margin than the shipping revenue you give up.
This is an estimate. It assumes your order values follow a typical spread around your average, and it relies on your guesses for top-ups and extra orders. Small changes to those move the answer a lot, so treat it as a starting point and A/B test the threshold.
How does the calculator pick a threshold?
It simulates 2,000 orders spread around your average order value, then tests every threshold from roughly 60% to 220% of your AOV. For each one it adds up the margin from bigger baskets and extra orders, minus the shipping revenue you give away, and picks the threshold that makes the most profit.
Why does the answer move so much when I change “extra orders”?
Because without extra orders, most thresholds lose money: you give free shipping to lots of orders that would have happened anyway, and top-ups rarely cover it. So the whole case for a threshold rests on how many more people buy when free shipping is in reach. That’s why it’s worth A/B testing.
What gross margin should I use?
Your margin after product cost, before shipping and marketing. If a £100 basket costs you £45 in stock, that’s 55%.
Does it account for VAT?
Keep it consistent: if your AOV and shipping charge include VAT, the profit figures are slightly flattering. For a sharper answer, enter AOV and shipping charge ex VAT.
How accurate is it?
It’s a well-reasoned starting point, not a guarantee. It assumes a typical spread of order values around your average. Your real order data, shipping costs by zone and margins by product will give a sharper answer.
Want this worked out on your real orders?
Book a free deep dive. I’ll run your actual Shopify order data, shipping costs by zone and weight, and margins by product to set a threshold you can trust, and point out any other profit leaks I spot along the way.